Topic RSS | Reply to topic
Author Post

teotwawki


Member

Posted Sun Jan 18th, 2009 11:22am Post subject: Fight or Flight error?
There was a question along the lines of: "Which direction does a rocket accelerate most?"

I'm fairly sure that the rocket's acceleration is exactly equal to it's force divided by it's mass - It's orientation is irrelevant.

E.g. If it were an unusually heavy rocket with a relatively weak chemical propellant, such that it only just managed to "hover" when aimed vertically up, then it's acceleration would still be the same 9.8m/s/s as when it appeared to rapidly disappear from sight when aimed horizontally toward the east.

Judging by the answer Stephen gave I would postulate the the question posed should have been: "To an outside observer standing still on the Earth, in which direction would the rocket appear to accelerate the most?"

You could have got another trap out of that one!

Back to top

erik


Member

Posted Fri Feb 6th, 2009 1:21pm Post subject: Fight or Flight error?
I'd think that acceleration would always be in relation to the former state. The former state would be standing still compared to the earth's surface. So I don't think there's anything wrong with the question anyway, but more importantly:

"Why butterflies?"

Stephen is allowed to ask unfair questions (especially in QI), in fact we expect it.
The answer to the question, by the way, is simply "Bats."

Back to top