Topic RSS | Reply to topic
Author Post

shatzi


Member

Posted Mon Sep 24th, 2007 2:24am Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
As well as BPD, I have dealt with abuse most of my life. I'm 41 now and far away from it but to make this short, I had two siblings attempt abuse on me, a mother who knew yet called me a liar and did nothing about it. Both parents treating the two just fine in front of me as if I were invisible and had no feelings. Mom also cut me down all the time. Told me I'd never be anything, I was stupid, whenever I had some goal or said I would do something good her response was always something like, "That'll be the day..." School was pretty much the same. I was bullied pretty bad til the day I graduated (we graduate at 18 over here). I was told college was out, no one had ever gone and the family didn't know about grants or financial aid. Had a few very abusive relationships and a marriage where I was a punching bag to a short little jerk for a few years until I tossed him out.
I'm a million miles away or so it seems. Nice house, college, nice car, parents both died, even a different name. Therapist told me the extreme hatred means I have not resolved the anger. Lots of anger that I never confronted Mom to ask why she treated me that way.
Question is...do I really have to forgive the bast***s to lose the anger and make the dreams and things go away? I flat out refuse to forgive anyone. They knew what they were doing, they didn't have a bad situation to blame, and I won't let anyone off the hook. One of the siblings is still bothering me over email, greedy over Dad's trust fund, and I finally told him off after all these years. He got nasty and told me my "meds must not be working."
I cannot forgive but there must be some other way to get past the rage since I know I cannot do anything about the past.
Anyone else dealing with a horrid past as well, and how do you cope?

Back to top

Saturn


Member

Posted Mon Sep 24th, 2007 10:08am Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
While not physically or sexually abused like you were; at school I was bullied constantly for the whole period of time, sometimes physically, mostly mentally though which has affected my life greatly.

I was so afraid of it happening again that when I went to University after leaving school I had such problems dealing with people I didn't even attempt to make any friends, have any kind of social life or anything. The opportunity of starting a whole new life was denied me because I was so petrified, so deeply depressed and had zero self-esteem and self-confidence.

I was always sensitive, extremely shy and easily hurt by people but this bulling just made me more and more depressed, more and more hateful of myself and I spent most of my teenage years and up to mid 20s alone, completely without a friend in the world.

I spent many years hating the people that done this to me, going over and over my school days being eaten up by hatred and loathing that I was unable to look at the future and see anything but more of the same bitterness, anger and regret.

Eventually, after seeing a psychologist I came to the realization that I had to let go of all that anger because it was destroying me. I had internalized the bullies, had been bullying myself constantly, always putting myself down and hating myself, blaming myself for what they did.

So I did, I just stopping hating them. I just decided I don;t care what those people think/thought of me, I know that I'm a good person, that I didn't deserve such abuse and treatment from those guys.

I don't know about forgiveness [that's mostly a Christian ethic] but I do know that I do not bear the people who tormented me any ill-will, in fact I feel sorry for them, sorry that they felt they had to do that to another person.

I'm not saying this has changed much for me, I still have severe social difficulties, problems with dealing with people, making friends and forming relationships and tend to avoid social situations because I still have extremely low self-esteem and self-confidence but I no longer have that hatred for others. I try and always see the best in people, until proved otherwise.

Don't know if that will help in your case but that's my story anyway.

The past is the past and no amount of thinking can change it, you can 0nly change the way you deal with it, and try and if not forgive, or forget try and learn that whatever happened was not your fault and that you can't change it.

Revenge will solve nothing, regret is rot.

I don't know what I'm saying I'm never very good at explaining but just try and learn to live with your past so you can look to a future free from hatred and bitterness.

xxx

Back to top

ruthy


Member

Posted Mon Sep 24th, 2007 12:11pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
I didn't have an abusive childhood, but I have been abused. Nowhere near as badly as you and I'm so sorry about that.
But what I wanted to say was that I'm a little suspicious about the idea that forgiveness will be helpful.

To me forgiveness means sort of telling yourself that it was ok for them to do what they did, which is wrong!

I'm not sure that letting go of anger is the same thing. Like Saturn says it's more like learning to live with the past and accepting that it is in the past.

At least I think that's what he meant, I'm sorry Saturn if I've misconstrued, my heads a bit fuzzy today!

Back to top

Anonymous


Unregistered

Posted Mon Sep 24th, 2007 12:16pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
Is the problem the anger at the people who hurt you or the anger you keep within yourself? In cases of sexual abuse, there is a certain propensity for the victim to blame themselves and for the mindset of 'I deserved it' to come about. You said you had a violent marriage: again, it's quite common for someone who's been abused to find a partner who continues that abuse. It's almost the self-fulfilling prophecy in a way.

The notion of forgive and forget is s shitty one to me. I can't forget things that people have done to me but I will come to terms with them if reasonable attempts to rectify the situaiton have been made. Sometimes though it's pointless. I know it's worthless trying to get along with my brother as a proper borther so we have a nothing relationship. I probably talk to the postman more than him and I live with this brother.

One tactic often used is to write letters to the people you fele hurt by but to not send those letters. It's a tool for releasing the anger, getting everything out physically. You try and keep in the emotions over the years but they churn up inside of you. It sounds like it's a good time for them to come out because life is more settled in terms of house, college etc. The exterior part of life is quite good but it's your interior with all your emotions and feelings that needs help.

Back to top

Anonymous


Unregistered

Posted Mon Sep 24th, 2007 2:28pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
Forgiveness isn't required and what works for one person won't work for another necessarily. I think you have to ask yourself this: is your anger hurting you more than letting go would? If your anger is only destructive and you feel capable of forgiving then, yes, forgive (although possibly not forget in that general, I-shan't-let-this-happen-again sort of way). If the anger works for you, isn't hurting yourself and others, or if you simply aren't in the head space needed to forgive then you don't need to just know now. But remember too, there is a difference between forgiving/forgetting and choosing to not do so, but still having a life that is not determined by those events.

A tall order I know, but I'm sure you can find the path that you need to find and follow it. You can do it.

Back to top

shatzi


Member

Posted Mon Sep 24th, 2007 8:07pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
Thanks for all the advice!
My anger and really rage is not so much at me, well, maybe it IS at me, the anger is of course to them for treating me like dirt, calling me a liar when they knew full well what was going on at home when they left me alone with the brothers, etc, but anger at me for not confronting Mom before she died and asking what the he** she was thinking.
A quick example. I was never in trouble, always a geeky goody two shoes. One brother was ALWAYS in trouble with the police. Mom always defended him. They (counselors) were thinking of "rewarding" him with a free ride at university to get him a degree/skill to maybe keep him out of trouble. Yes, while I had to work to PAY my own way through and couldn't finish, hence I'm back in university now. Want to add insult to injury? When I told mom, 'Gee maybe if I commit a crime over in Oakwood (the posh part of town) I can get a scholarship to Princeton" she just got angry and said something like "Shutup, you always have to pick on him about something don't you?" This was the same cretin who attempted to molest me, tried to molest our nephew and other kids, and this time was in trouble for armed robbery. Imagine growing up wiht THIS rubbish.
I've already told off one of them just last Friday. There is fighing going on over a trust fund, yes money of course, this brother is greedy and making chaos. I have cut off all contact, blocked his email, etc. AFTER getting the last word hee hee. The therapist said something about writing letters and mailing them to finish this business, and I did write them and will mail them. As for the parents, she said I could write to them and then burn them. I may try that.
Yes, I went through the same thing with alienating myself, no friends. To this day, if I am in a group or somewhere and people laugh I grimace for a second thinking they may be laughing at me, after all the abuse. But it's getting a lot better.
Thanks for the advice and this board! I've already confessed more here than to anyone else I know.

Back to top

tracy8673


Member

Posted Mon Sep 24th, 2007 9:47pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
The letter writing idea is one I have used with great results. To cut a very long story short (ish), my Dad buggered off with another woman when I was 22 and it devestated the family. My own relationship with my father became very strained as it seemed that this woman came first in everything and he refused to give me any time. When I decided to get married abroad in 2000 he cut me off. We were both very stubborn, but I still loved him and I ached to have my Dad back and for my son to have a granddad. Anyway, he died, suddenly at the age of 50 almost 4 years ago. His wife and sister closed ranks and made it difficult for me to even find out the funeral plans. I was told that I could attend the funeral (!) but I had to wait outside the crematorium. I wasn't even allowed to follow the procession in my own car. I was told to stay away from his house. My own brother, it transpired, was part of this. He travelled with them in the funeral car. So as I stood, alone, they all got out of the car and not one of them looked at me. It was as if it were my fault that he was dead! I cannot describe the sheer anger I felt towards them. This was my Dad.

Anyway, during a counselling session last year, it was suggested that to let go of some of the anger I felt towards them, I should write letters. I did just that - absolutely no holds barred. One to my Brother and one to my Dad's Sister. Told them how my Dad would never have wanted me to have been treated like that. How ashamed they should feel. Told them that if they bothered to write back, I would just put the letter straight into the rubbish unread. I didn't write to his widow - I called her on the phone. Asked her why she did it. She realised that she'd done wrong. Although she didn't apologise, just getting it off my chest was enough.

I never received replies to my letters, but the anger just seemed to melt. The memory doesn't rip me up inside any more. Tits to them!

Post those letters, but don't read the replies!

I hope you find peace.

Tracy xx

Back to top

shatzi


Member

Posted Mon Sep 24th, 2007 11:28pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
I will do that, I think I need to express what I have bottled up. Oh, but laugh at them at the same time. I am doing very well for someone who was always called a stupid loser. I guess I can get the last laugh.
I have no problem with hating and anger and resentment, with giving them that kind of power but I find I never let myself cry, over anything. That makes me feel like they have control, even though no one would know if I would cry over things. I have not cried in years.
I will let let the genie out, send them all my thoughts, and never bother with them again. I have blocked his email, have caller ID so I won't answer any phone calls, and if we must meet up ever about this trust fund (though I am 10 hours away) I will not utter a word. I may even dig out some old photos tonight and burn them. Anything I can to heal. 41 years is too long to let the rage make me lonely, mess up my work, and make me bungle a test last week over his batch of hate mail.
As you are all my witnesses, never again! I promised my therapist this too, and one thing, I never break a promise.

Back to top

Vespertine


Member

Posted Tue Sep 25th, 2007 12:15am Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
I was abused very young as a child. I don't remember much, if anything, really about it. But it hurts subconsciously. It's a pity you remember. And that is by no means supposed to sound patronizing. I really feel for you. No one should have to go through what you did.

And unfortunately, often come a follow up of abusive relationships. I know, I feel into the same trap a couple of times.

I've never had the best relationship with my mum but it could certainly be worse, so I know how painful it can be to be beaten down by the one person who's supposed to believe in you.

I'm Buddhist so I believe forgiving is in everyone somewhere, but I realise how difficult it is also. Just because I meditate doesn't mean I don't feel anger from time to time
For me, Forgive isn't the right word or even action. I believe its acceptance, like the other folk have mentioned.

I'm sorry I have nothing that noone else has said.

If you need me for any reason PM me. My ears are always open!

Back to top

Red Raven


Member

Posted Tue Sep 25th, 2007 12:28am Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
I won't forgive him.

That's all I have to say about that.

Back to top

shatzi


Member

Posted Tue Sep 25th, 2007 3:54am Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
Well tonight I took a photo album and a few old things I still have and put them in the attic. But first I pulled out the few old black and white pics of me as a kid with the siblings and one of mom, wrote a letter with all the things I would like to say to her, then put the pic and letter in the fireplace and torched them.
I feel better already.
All of this made me realize something. I have not thought of seriously committing suicide because I think I already have. I have a different last name, and other than legally in college etc, I like to go by a nickname which I use here. I finally had a bump taken out of my nose this year, had lasik to get rid of the glasses last year, live far away, have new interests from what I did 20 years ago, am not afraid of people like I used to be, I'm very different from that old person I used to hate. I have in a way killed her off. Tonight I rid myself of the skeletons. I even put in that letter for them to stop haunting my life and my sleep.
I hope all this doesn't sound too strange, but if it works and takes the weight off my shoulders I'll let you know. Thanks for all the comments. Abuse, no matter what type, lasts a very long time. This board is great therapy!!

Back to top

holdthenewsreadersnose


Member

Posted Tue Sep 25th, 2007 10:05am Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
FWIW, I think that some people here are looking at this all wrong. Forgiveness doesn't mean that it was okay that someone hurt you; it doesn't mean that you have to invite them over and be best friends; it doesn't even mean that you have to let them know that they are forgiven. However, it does mean that you can put the past to bed and move on without having negative feelings every time something reminds you of that particular person/event. The only people who suffer from your holding onto bitterness are yourselves and those close to you.

Back to top

Anonymous


Unregistered

Posted Wed Sep 26th, 2007 12:43pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
Isn't it rather bizarre, though, that Christianity and Buddhism talk of forgiveness, yet many atheists would rather burn with hate. The irony is that forgiveness has more to do with a psychological apporach to humanity; the realisation that whatever harm someone has done was the result of something - past abuse, trauma, obsessive behaviour or even (and let's not forget this is a strong possibility) disorders of the type that many forum members suffer from themselves.
On the other hand, not forgiving suggests a belief in human evil which is rather Old Testament in style (he/she did it because he/she was just plain evil), rather than rationally and logically appreciating that while the abused was in no way to blame themselves, there had to be a catalyst somewhere.

Back to top

Saturn


Member

Posted Wed Sep 26th, 2007 1:03pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
Isn't it rather bizarre, though, that Christianity and Buddhism talk of forgiveness, yet many atheists would rather burn with hate.

Hmm not sure about that.

As for the Old Testament, I don't remember much talk of forgiveness in that sinister book - the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, the flood, an eye for an eye etc. The Old Testament God is one of vengeance, destruction and fear.

I was brought up as a strict Catholic, had the Bible forced upon me, but lost, or abandoned my faith in my teens, I was always taught to forgive, yet it was not until I became more of an interest in the humanities, that I began to look at my past and begin to philosophically digest what had happened and absolve myself and those responsible from any inbuilt, or inherent evil, or predisposition to do wrong.

Back to top

Anonymous


Unregistered

Posted Wed Sep 26th, 2007 1:06pm Post subject: Forgive and Forget? Forget It..
I'm not condemning Shatzi though. Whatever reasons there may be for her family's treatment of her, I couldn't imagine being able to forgive or forget in her shoes. There but for the grace of God...

Back to top