|
timroberts

Member
|
Posted Sun Jul 4th, 2010 8:32pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
Hello Stephen,
Thank-you for your serious and intelligent programme on Wagner. No-one can ban or demolish such music. But why haven't the Germans demolished that terrible place in Nuremburg, the great set for Leni Reifenstahl's super-opera films? I admired you for going there, and improvising (as it seemed) so movingly to camera.
I wonder if you know of the dissenting Wagner great-grandson, Gottfried? He's a musicologist, and I remember a TV film he made some years ago in which he technically analysed the discomfort HE clearly feels when listening to his ancestor's music, arguing that there is something inherently dishonest in Wagner's technique - comparable to the dishonesty of Nazi politics. In the music it's a question of the voice and melodic instruments being continually backed by those half-perceptible horns, tubas etc., which get you hooked without you knowing why...
One can see what he means. Nordic twilight rather than the idealised Grecian clarity. But as for honesty - what is 'honesty' in great art? ...
There's an interesting read at
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/anti-semitism/Wagner.html
Thank-you again.
Tim Roberts
|
|
timroberts

Member
|
Posted Mon Jul 5th, 2010 1:44am Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
ps There's a good book review, if you're interested in Gottfried Wagner, at
http://www.bostonphoenix.com/archive/books/99/06/0.....RS_TH.html
TR
|
|
heatherthevet

Member
|
Posted Sun Jul 11th, 2010 3:40pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
I was wondering if any Wagnerite could tell me what the music that comes in at the end of the piece to camera on the Nuremberg steps around 50mins in is? Most of the snippets are identified as they come up, but not that bit which turned my head.
I enjoyed the programme for many reasons, although I've never been especially in to Wagner. Put some Puccini on and I'll melt onto the floor though. Anyway, I had a very enjoyable hour on iplayer and will have much to chew on for the rest of the day
|
|
Elbow21

Member
|
Posted Sun Jul 11th, 2010 3:57pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
I liked the program .I had only ever heard of Wagner and now I know ore about him.His views were unacceptable but his music was good and it has made me more interested in classical music.
|
|
miranda

Member
|
Posted Thu Aug 5th, 2010 10:00pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
KingLudwigII said:
Stephen thank you so much for making your recent programme on Wagner. Like you the first music I ever heard by Wagner was the prelude to Tannhauser when I was a child. I've visted Neuswanstein and revelled in the ecstacy of the operas. I can see how Wagner can become an obsession, a passion, an addiction almost!
Brilliant Programme, please make another!!
Ludwig
And Im another. I loved it that Steven met Tannhauser as a child. It reminded me of my introduction to the notion of ecstatic music, as a seven or eight year old at boarding school. While the school filed into assembly every morning, juniors like me going first, sitting cross legged on the floor till everyone was in, they used to play music on the gramophone. Among the pieces the recurred occasionally was the overture to Tannhauser.. and the pilgrim's chorus... o bliss !! o heaven. o iresistable. These very physical early pieces got right through to a dozey little girl in grey ankle socks, regardless of the gossip and fidgeting around me.
Do any schools offer young children stuff like this now ? Real music, the stillness of listening ?
|
|
timbeak

Member
|
Posted Tue Aug 17th, 2010 2:44am Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
Stephen
Enjoyed the show on Wagner immensely, as I am a Bass Trombonist, Wagner lover and an American of German descent (on my Dad's side mostly). I have always felt a bit guilty for the association of Wagner to Hitler and it was interesting to see you struggle with all of the aspects of Wagner. Think of Wagner as the Sinatra of Opera. The man and his MUSIC. Definitely both complex individuals and artists who transformed their respective musical worlds. (Maybe not so great on a personal level).
|
|
spikeq

Member
|
Posted Fri Oct 1st, 2010 9:29pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
I am not a particular fan of yours, Stephen; however, your programme on Wagner was simply superb. I found so much common ground with you, and I am delighted that your views reflect mine (and, no doubt many others) so well and describe them so much more articulately than I could ever manage. I too feel the deep, indescribable emotions generated by the music, and I am not ashamed to say that when the Tristan love duet was played, tears coursed down my cheeks with no encouragement at all. The views of the participants in the programme also helped me to reconcile my passion for Wagner with my horror of the Nazi period and also with my Catholic Faith. Truly the music overwhelms me and as Bernard Levin once said (I think) "Wagner's music is such that I can forgive him his failings" In summary, a superb programme, Stephen, which deserved a fair greater airing. No doubt it will be aired as rarely as Wagner's work is on the BBC, to the detriment of many.
Thank You Mate.
|
|
spikeq

Member
|
Posted Fri Oct 1st, 2010 9:42pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
I think it is the "Wach Auf" chorus, to which you refer. It is used (in separate parts) throughout the Nurnberg portion of the programme. It comes from "Die Meistersingern von Nurnberg" and I think it is the final act when the the grand ceremony is about to take place. Do enjoy your music, and I am sure that a little patience will reveal a wonderfully deep passion within Wagner, that truly gets inside you and grows with you. In modern vernacular, I feel that Wagner is truly Kewel!
heatherthevet said:
I was wondering if any Wagnerite could tell me what the music that comes in at the end of the piece to camera on the Nuremberg steps around 50mins in is? Most of the snippets are identified as they come up, but not that bit which turned my head.
I enjoyed the programme for many reasons, although I've never been especially in to Wagner. Put some Puccini on and I'll melt onto the floor though. Anyway, I had a very enjoyable hour on iplayer and will have much to chew on for the rest of the day
|
|
spikeq

Member
|
Posted Fri Oct 1st, 2010 9:50pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
Do please "delve in to the Ring Cycle" - you will be rewarded beyond your dreams if you simply sit and immerse yourself into the passion that pours from it
CreamyOldEngland said:
Fantastic programme. Stephen's obvious enthusiasm throughout was great fun, he seemed quite unaware of the camera sometimes, especially when he was working through 'Tristan...' on the piano. It reminded of when he was on 'Room 101' and wanted to make a programme called 'Room Lovely' about all the good things in life.
Tackling the perennially thorny subject of 'the art not the artist' was the most obvious requirement of any programme on the subject and it was done with the usual sensitivity and lucidity one would expect.
If one of the main intentions was to get people listening then it worked for that too. I am emboldened now to tackle the Ring cycle. I am afraid I am one of those people who have snacked on the arias but has never managed to eat a whole opera so its manifold riches have become something I must, must delve into.
Thanks.
|
|
writetowrite

Member
|
Posted Fri Oct 22nd, 2010 10:57am Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
What I know about classical music could be written on the back of a postage stamp, but given my recent quest for knowledge, I embarked upon listening to some of Wagner's music this very morning. The plan; to see whether Stephen's programme would be of any interest to me.
Dear Lord, I almost crumpled in a heap! Sometimes, in ones life, one is drawn to something in a way that cannot be described... indeed, can only be 'felt'. I am so deeply moved. I am also both annoyed that it has taken me 41 years to 'discover' Wagner, and delighted that I finally have... in equal measure. All because Stephen made this TV programme.
Wagner's is some of the most beautiful and most powerful music I have ever heard. I don't know what else I can say. I have a cup of tea and a choccie bickie waiting and I'm going to put my feet up and indulge some more.
Music is wonderful... exploration is wonderful... discovery is wonderful. 'Life' is wonderful. Blimey... I don't know what's come over me.
"Rational arguments don't usually work on religious people. Otherwise, there would 'be' no religious people". Dr Gregory House.
thewritetowrite
|
|
nollaig

Member
|
Posted Sat Feb 19th, 2011 8:57pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
May I please ask for your help everyone? I am generally very intimidated by classical music and in particular Wagner.
My question is “where do I begin listening to Wagner?” Which conductor? Which orchestra? What recording?
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Nollaig
|
|
Digital Classics

Member
|
Posted Tue Feb 22nd, 2011 11:36am Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
I'm glad that everyone enjoyed Wagner & Me. We really enjoyed working on the release and are pleased that it is now available on DVD in the UK.
The producers very kindly put together an extra 36 minutes of bonus interviews and performances exclusive to this release.
Heatherthevet: Yes, that piece is from Act 3 of Die Meistersinger.
If you want to track down the exact recording, it is from:
Cat No: Naxos 8557714
Track 1 Mastersingers Excerpt Act 3 (Wagner Opera Choruses)
If anybody has any other queries about the film, post it and we will try to answer.
|
|
mcc377

Member
|
Posted Tue Apr 26th, 2011 12:49pm Post subject: Stephen on Wagner
Just a humble old train driver here making an observation. As with others i find the Tanhauser overture very emotive and thoroughly enjoyed Stephen's programme on Wagner. Given his anti semite character and and as uncomfortable as that is, his music is as popular as ever. To put that into a modern context, I note with interest that the music of a certain Gary Glitter is no longer aired in the media due to his abhorent crimes. However, is the music 'detachable' from the composer? Just a thought.
Matt
|