Topic RSS | Reply to topic
Author Post

Roundcat


Member

Posted Sat May 29th, 2010 7:04am Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

Having just got my iPad I downloaded Stephen's blog page. It's all rather marvellous and clever i(f a little light on new material) but I'm enjoying it's existence never the less.
I do, sadly, have one issue and that's with the blog about voting in the election where Stephen says people who don't feel their vote matters and as such don't bother voting are cowardly.

I didn't vote, because I didn't want to vote for any of the options particularly. As it turns out had I been someone who would of voted labour, the fact of the matter is the MY vote would not of mattered because Labour won in West Ealing (where is live) by a 1000's of votes.

I felt bad that Stephen was calling people like me cowardly as sometimes peoples beliefs are personal. We do not like to think of ourselves as an organism in a huge beast where if we all work together our vote will count. The truth is I probably am cowardly but not because I thought my vote wouldn't matte.

The argument that 'well if everybody thought like you... Nobody would vote' is very true. If everybody didn't vote then we would be in trouble, but Stephen wasn't talking about everybody, he was talking about individuals, me, you and whoever else felt like I did.

My vote would not of mattered. It's a fact and I was right to stay in an watch Bad Lieutenant instead.


Back to top

joan


Member

Posted Sat May 29th, 2010 8:59am Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

I think your non-vote was a positive abstention rather than a negative vote. You determined that no party or candidate was worth your vote, so you refused to give it. I don't think Stephen was on about people like you, who thought it through.

Every vote does count though, because you just never know. One polling day in 1996 I cast my vote, thinking that it would have made little difference anyway, in this safe Labour seat. BUT, a racist populist woman was standing, and she pushed all the scary buttons in people who are not very politically savvy. and got elected. I was horrified, but felt good that my Labour vote had proven to myself at least, that I did not support racist policies.

(Three years later the seat reverted to Labour and she never got back in. I had been part of the anti-racist movement that ousted her)


Back to top

gadgetgirl


Member

Posted Sat May 29th, 2010 9:58am Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

A few years back I was feeling particularly disenfranchised with all of my candidates in a local election. I turned up to the polling station, wrote a message saying this on the card and posted it in the box.

I know that the returning officers have to go through every card determining if a positive vote has been made or not as my friend has worked as one. I knew it would be read so I was passing on my protest that way.

Btw, apparently they will get some ballot papers with things like the X in a box for labour and a "F*** off" written on the BNP candidates name. That would count as a positive vote for someone!

However, this is the reason that I would like to see PR brought in - it's a much more fair system to the voters. I know there are those who are scared about far right parties getting in but I very much suspect none of the main parties would ever work with them and their impact would be minimal. Also the reality of actually having them elected may bring to light how bad they are - as it appears to have done in this election in the UK.

That would be me.

Back to top

joan


Member

Posted Sat May 29th, 2010 10:32am Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

We have preferential voting here in Australia and it works very well. You just put numbers in the boxes instead of X for the one you want. So mine would be Labour candidate 1. Greens 2, Democrats 3 and Tory 4 etc etc. If Labour or Tories, for example, got over 50% of the votes, preferences would be ignored, but if there was no clear winner, second preferences would be counted as full votes, and a winner would emerge.

We also have compulsory voting - you have to turn up at the polling booth and get your voting slip. Of course, you can drop it into the box blank if you want. Many do, many more put Micky Mouse, Donald Duck, Jesus Christ, or any daft name they can come up with. I've often been a scrutineer at elections, and we usually have informal bets about how many votes Micky Mouse will get.

Because it is compulsory, polling booths are everywhere - very handy - and postal votes are easy.


Back to top

HollyLouise


Member

Posted Wed Jun 2nd, 2010 1:30am Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

You might not think your vote counts, but think how many people say that. It could make a difference in a particular constituency if all the people who think their votes aren't worthwhile actualy voted.

For example, in a very small constituency only a few votes can make all the difference. I'd say that you should always use your vote wisely. Read up on the policies of all the parties, and don't just think nationally. Too many people vote for who they want to be prime minister, and yes that is important, but you're escentialy voting in who you want to be your local mp. If that person has fundamental beliefs that you don't agree with think carefully about voting them in. It's not the leader of their party that'll represent you locally. I think too many people forget that.

All i'm saying is be wise when you vote, and remember you are actualy voting in someone to represent your local comunity.

Back to top

LeJeunesse


Member

Posted Wed Jun 23rd, 2010 11:43pm Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

My vote (if I was old enough) has very little impact. Where I live, because of the large lib dem/ tory percentage of vote and the 9% labour and the rediculous ways of FPTP, I have five times less of a vote than average. So my vote would count for relatively little. Hence why I am in favour of some sort of PR system, though I think the referendum the tories are promising is a cop out and will still let them play to their advantage of rural sparsely populated tory voting areas. I am medium left wing libertarian, and out of the three main parties would vote for labour. I would never vote tory. Ever. So that leaves me with a middle ground of 'acceptable' lib dems, who usually win my constituency (though them ConDemming me has made them a far less attractive option). I would want to vote labour, but where I live this is just basically making it one vote easier for the tories so to keep them out I'd have to vote Lib Dem or else my vote would be 'wasted'. This is rediculous. I am voting for who I want to control my country and my future and I am not being allowed to do so. I shouldn't have to comprimise my ideals. FPTP is a disgrace. However, I would never not vote. I can understand why you didnt though, and I know quite a few people who spoiled their paper in protest writing things such as 'FPTP sucks' and one drew a stick man being hung with 'democracy' written in his head. I think the people he is calling cowards are those who didnt even think about it.

Some people say that PR will allow extremist parties in and dont get me wrong I want Nick Griffin in parliament like I want hole in the head, however, I do want democracy and if anyone votes for him, they deserve to be reprisented, no matter who they voted for. I disagree with them but they should be able to say it and if people fall for that, well then democracy, what I believe in, says that they should be reprisented. Besides, it would be a very small amount comparitivily speaking. The only reason governments havent brought it in thus far is that it would dramatically increase lib dem seats and decrease, particularly, the tory seats. Though I am predicting lib dem votes to go down next time as many people have been annoyed by the alliance made with the tories.

Gadgetgirl, are you in England? Because that would be a spoiled ballot as it has written on it anything but a cross in the box I think.

Anyway, I just realised that this turned into a PR rant, sorry But it is in the ranting section

"that woman...of dubious and questionable memory." :P

@twitter

Back to top

joan


Member

Posted Thu Jun 24th, 2010 8:19am Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

Our system here in Australia got a BNP-type person elected in 1996 to federal parliament - in a seat representing my area. One in two of my neighbours voted for her, much to my deep disgust.

BUT - she showed herself and her racism up in her maiden speech - it was awful: she talked about being swamped by Asians (ie Chinese and Vietnamese) and said there was no Aboriginal disadvantage etc etc. No one would sit near her in parliament, her supporters were often shunned, and she never ever got reelected to any seat anywhere.

Her maiden speech haunted me for a while - I knew I'd read something just like it before. Then it hit me like a bombshell - it reminded me of Hitler's Mein Kampf. So I made myself sick by reading Mein Kampf again, and publishing 10 things from her speech that were common to her and Hitler! I was just one of loads of anti-racist activists, and we defeated her through showing exactly what her ideas were, and where they could lead.

Often, with people like the BNP leader, you just need to give them enough rope and they hang themselves.


Back to top

LeJeunesse


Member

Posted Thu Jun 24th, 2010 10:22am Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

I agree, Nick Griffin makes me feel sick. However, as much as I dislike that people vote for them, they deserve to have their vote reprisented as much as you or I. What we must concentrate on is, like you have, showing their true colours and convincing people not to vote for them. I find that if they get anywhere near power, they end up showing who they really are and they end up loosing votes.

Did you see when an egg was thrown at the BNP leader here in England? As much as I disagree with 'violence', it made me laugh. Especially the stills later shown of his smug face.

"that woman...of dubious and questionable memory." :P

@twitter

Back to top

fluffy morals


Member

Posted Tue Jul 27th, 2010 5:27pm Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

i think voting is like wearing a poppy for remembrance sunday, i may not have been there and i dislike the modern military( that point i'll have to expand on in another post, still working on articulating it) but in spite of that i contribute to the ceremony of war. I neither like or dislike politicians, i do think they're spoiled, i think the parliamentary process is laced with conspiracy...
everyone and every demographic has its issues but here my point when you consider the fights and the sacrifices made by generations for todays generation (and the next) not go through in the inequities of their experience on the planet, i think the least a person who enjoys the trappings of a democracy could take part for one hour every four years.
How would you feel if those people on this planet, who had no vested interest in the future(children and grandchildren) decided that they'd continue they're existence with no thought of the future for others.
And i think the use of cowardly may mean you dont vote (subconsciously) because you don't like having a affiliation with a losing side.THIS is my first post and i think i got the run of myself, if i did I apologise and for not being more concise, i shall work on my GRAMMAR AND BREVITY AND typing skills so as not to hit the caps lock i've never subscribed to a blog or forum before so i'm still navigating its mechanisms, thanks for reading, Chaaat

Fluffy Morals JBK

Back to top

amyl_nitrate


Member

Posted Thu Aug 12th, 2010 1:43pm Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

fluffy morals said:
i think voting is like wearing a poppy for remembrance sunday, i may not have been there and i dislike the modern military( that point i'll have to expand on in another post, still working on articulating it) but in spite of that i contribute to the ceremony of war. I neither like or dislike politicians, i do think they're spoiled, i think the parliamentary process is laced with conspiracy...
everyone and every demographic has its issues but here my point when you consider the fights and the sacrifices made by generations for todays generation (and the next) not go through in the inequities of their experience on the planet, i think the least a person who enjoys the trappings of a democracy could take part for one hour every four years.

That's how I feel. People died so future generations could have a fair and anonymous vote. I am thankful that I live in a time and place where I can vote. Even if FPTP is unfair and all the main parties seem to be becoming more and more centred I still believe in exercising my right to vote, to have the opportunity to make a choice. The thought of any of us (whether specific groups of people or a whole nation) losing the right to vote is a terrifying one. I am for proportional representation but will be happy if alternative vote get's in as a first step.

Assuming direct control...

Back to top

Anthony Miller


Member

Posted Wed Sep 22nd, 2010 5:11pm Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

"My vote would not of mattered. It's a fact"

No, it's an inference... Actually

In closely faught elections like the one we just had vote share not just the number of seats is very important too and affects the politician's mandate to govern within their own party/coalition
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/election_2010/8661593.stm

You may think it is easier living in a marginal constituency but it really isn't. We've been through three MPs in the last 3 elections. One who cheated on expenses so badly it was discovered before the actual expenses scandal, one who was alleged to have hit is second wife and then took six months off sick and schismed the Tory party, and Lord Ashcroft's minion Gavin Barwell who spent so much money he has had to seek relief in the high court over his election expenses.
The higher the voter turnout the the more the party spends in that constituency. There are limited financial resources so that means that they cant spend as much money in marginal constituencies.
If you're in a marginal seat you get the real dross candidates...

Trust me - EVERY vote REALLY DOES count even under First Past the Post.
So always vote - even if it's Monster Raving Loony.
And if you really cant find anyone who represents your views join the local party and bring it down from within!
My Fry speaks the truth.
We are now getting the chance to possibly change from FPP to AV+ and it wont happen unless YOU vote for it!

http://www.pearshapedcomedy.com

Back to top

frightfullychuffed


Inactive

Posted Thu Oct 7th, 2010 2:22pm Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

Yes it's true. Every vote counts and every count votes. If you don't vote don't complain about the government, there, see. It's alright pet, after the first time you get quite fearless about it, and could even try voting twice. I did once. Do it for your country otherwise your country will do it to you. Fry is bang on the money.

next

Back to top

boilerman


Member

Posted Thu Oct 7th, 2010 6:57pm Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

Hey Roundcat, do what your happy with,its your vote.I have no idea what SF means by that anyway.
Where I live its a tory stronghold and nothing left of centre for me to vote for,so I vote Labour I thank my dad for making sure voting day was a ritual for me." dont matter where you put it,just put it" ofcourse now I,m older and about his age now(if you know what I mean)I see it as a challenge and a chance to tell these pasty faced supposed budding politions what I think of them.I love life


Back to top

grunthos the flatulent


Member

Posted Sat Nov 6th, 2010 11:20pm Post subject: Why did Mr Fry call me a coward?

LeJeunesse said:
I agree, Nick Griffin makes me feel sick.

I actually quite like the guy. The man's so slimy, so laughable, so idiotic, so inarticulate, and so unable to hide the disgusting policies of his party that they failed dismally to make any progress at the last election. On that basis I hope he remains as BNP leader for a very, very long time.


Back to top